Why Your SDRs Are Working the Wrong Leads (And How Lead Scoring Fixes It)

Sort your SDR queue by created date and read the top ten.

If it's purely chronological, the student who filled out a form at 9:02 gets called before the VP who's been on your pricing page three times since Tuesday. The longer that VP sits, the less likely the call turns into a conversation.

Your SDRs aren't lazy. They're working without a way to prioritize, so they either call everything (not sustainable) or cherry-pick what looks obvious (and your best-fit accounts sit untouched). A lead scoring model with real-time intent alerts fixes that.

The problem with "just route everything to the SDR"

Treating every lead the same burns rep time on poor fits while the good ones go cold.

The fix is telling each rep, every morning, which accounts are in market right now and why. It doesn't take more SDRs.

Two scores

A lot of scoring models are one number. You need two, because they measure different things and lead to different actions.

Fit: is this the right kind of person to buy from you? Company size, industry, title, seniority, tech stack. It barely changes. A VP at a 50-person Series B SaaS company has a high fit score whether or not she visited today.

Intent: is this person acting like a buyer right now? Pages visited, downloads, email clicks, webinars, repeat visits in a short window. It changes constantly.

High intentLow intent
High fitRep, todayNurture, keep warm
Low fitFlag and look, don't over-investAutomated nurture only

One combined score hides the student with 80 intent points behind the VP with 80 fit points.

Building the fit score in HubSpot

HubSpot's lead scoring tool handles fit well. You're assigning points to contact properties.

Start with the data you have. Check your database first: what share of records have a job title? Company size? Industry? A scoring model built on mostly blank fields scores mostly nothing.

Starting points, to calibrate against your ICP (the method is in building a model from closed-won deals):

  • On your target account list: +25
  • Title matches your buyer (VP, Director, Head of): +20
  • Company size in range: +15
  • Industry match: +15
  • Tech stack match (uses Salesforce, say): +10
  • Personal email: -10
  • Company too small or too large: -15
  • Student or academic email: -20
  • Competitor domain: -50

Set a fit threshold. Above it, a contact can get SDR attention. Below it, automated nurture.

Building the intent score

The step that gets skipped: weight signals by how close they are to a purchase.

An email click is weak intent. A third pricing page visit in five days is strong intent. Weighting them the same is why scoring models feel wrong.

  • Strong: demo or trial request +40 (route it now, don't wait for math), pricing page +15 (+25 for a second visit within 14 days), ROI calculator or comparison download +20, three or more pages in a session +15, back on the site within 7 days +10.
  • Medium: webinar attendance +15, webinar registration +10, case study download +10, relevant blog post +5.
  • Weak: email click +3, social ad click +3, any other page +1.

Leave email opens out. Apple's mail privacy feature and corporate security scanners open emails nobody read.

Make it decay. Someone active 90 days ago and silent since is not the same as someone active last week. If your scoring tool doesn't decay on its own, run a recurring workflow that lowers intent for contacts with no tracked activity in 30 days.

The routing

With two scores, routing is a workflow triggered by thresholds.

  • SDR now (high fit, high intent): urgent task for the assigned SDR, due today, plus a real-time alert. On Professional, the task can prompt the rep to enroll, or you can set enrollment triggers from the Automation tab inside the sequence tool, if your portal has it. Enrolling straight from a workflow needs Sales Hub or Service Hub Enterprise, and the sender needs a Sales seat and a connected inbox.
  • Nurture (high fit, low intent): long-cycle nurture, no rep task. If intent crosses the line later, it escalates to the SDR route.
  • Straight to the AE (open opportunity or past SQL): skip the SDR. Notify the AE with context. Don't make a known buyer start over with a junior rep.
  • Not a fit (low fit): automated nurture only. If intent is unusually high, flag it for marketing. They might be telling you your ICP is too narrow.

The alert is what changes behavior

Routing builds the right tasks. Alerts are what make reps act in real time instead of working the queue top to bottom.

A good alert says who, what happened, and what to do next.

Bad: "Jordan Lee has a high lead score."

Good: "Jordan Lee, VP Operations at Acme (fit 85, intent 62), visited pricing twice today and downloaded the ROI calculator. Third visit this week. Reach out in the next two hours and mention the calculator."

Build it as a workflow notification with tokens for name, company, scores and the activity that triggered it. Send it to Slack as well as the CRM, because tasks get buried.

If the alert doesn't say why, the rep writes "just checking in."

Add the account layer

Account scoring adds the company view.

Three contacts at one account each crossing an engagement line in 30 days is organizational intent, even if none of them is an MQL yet. Add up contact intent across the account, set an account threshold, and send that alert to the AE or account owner, not the SDR: "Acme has four people engaging this month. Here's who. Coordinate outreach so one rep doesn't own every thread." (The full version: account scoring and MQAs.)

How you'll know it's calibrated

Contact rate by score tier. High-score leads should turn into conversations more often than low-score ones. If they don't, the fit criteria or the intent weights are off.

Time from alert to first touch. If it's over four hours, the alerts aren't changing anything. Check that reps see them and that acting is easy.

MQL to SQL by score band. Leads routed above the threshold should become SQLs at a clearly higher rate than leads below it. If not, the threshold is wrong.

Check these monthly for the first quarter and expect to move the thresholds at least once.

Start with what closed

The Lead Scorecard & ICP Template

Code your won and lost deals and get your ICP in plain English, fit points, and a scorecard that grades any lead list A to D. Excel or Google Sheets. $49.

See the template

Ready to put scoring in your CRM? See the Lead Scoring & Routing Kit.

The newsletter

Notes from the Field.

Every other week, one broken thing and how I’d fix it.

One email every other week · unsubscribe anytime · Privacy policy